Reading time: 5 minutes
The Rosetta Stone laid the groundwork for our understanding of Ancient Egyptian language and culture when French scholar Jean-François Champollion cracked its code in September 1822. But the Rosetta Stone isn’t the only unsolved puzzle out there. Since the discovery of the Indus Valley Civilisation in the 1920s, the Indus Valley Script has remained an enigma, resisting all attempts at decipherment. From the origins of the civilisation to the reasons why the script remains undecoded, and what the future may hold, unlocking the Indus Valley Script could reveal important insights into one of history’s great ancient cultures.
By Nina Colleen Sumner
Exploring the Indus Valley Civilisation
The Indus Valley Civilisation (also known as IVC or the Harappan Civilisation) is described as a Bronze Age civilisation that lasted from 3300 BCE to 1300 BCE. The IVC existed in the northwestern regions of South Asia, extending from what is modern day northeast Afghanistan to Pakistan and northwest India. The Indus civilisation’s settlements spanned an area greater than that of Ancient Egypt at its peak. Indus jewellery examples have been found as far as Mesopotamia (around 1,500 miles away), highlighting its connection to the wider world through trade.
The Indus cities were sophisticated for the time, being built on a grid pattern with drains that carried sewage from homes emptying outside the city walls. While this demonstrates the significance of the Indus civilisation, there are still mysteries being discovered — and many left to uncover. Over time, scientists have continued to unlock the secrets of the Indus Valley Civilisation, human bones found by archaeologists have been the subject of two new studies, in which researchers “have found intriguing clues to the makeup of one city’s population.” For example, bones have revealed that many of the deceased found in a Harappan cemetery are from people who grew up outside of the city, revealing significant immigration to the city.
Dissecting the challenges involved
Not much is known regarding the language (or languages) of the Indus Valley Civilisation. The language of the IVC is referred to as the Harappan language, though the language is officially considered ‘unknown.’ As a result, the language is unclassified, though it’s possible that it could belong to the Dravidian language family. This, however, is only a slice of the theories and hypotheses out there. Bahata Ansumali Mukhopadhyay, an independent researcher who has analysed historical evidence regarding language. Mukhopadhyay went on to find that words used for ‘elephant’ in the Bronze Age Mesopotamia were borrowed from ‘pilu,’ a Proto-Dravidian word for elephant — this is noted to be “prevalent in the Indus Valley Civilisation.” Mukhopadhyay’s research, published in Nature Humanities and Social Sciences Communications “indicates the possibility of Proto-Dravidian speakers migrating from Indus valley to South India,”.
The Indus script was mainly written with signs that could symbolically convey meanings to people of different dialects, and languages, across Indus settlements. Over one hundred attempts have been made by scholars across different fields to try and decode the Indus script, all without success. There are a number of theories surrounding the language, potentially linking it to Sanskrit, Dravidian, Mesopotamian, or even Egyptian. However, it’s also pointed out that the script may not be in any one language, either, further complicating its already puzzling nature.
There are many challenges and various theories involved in trying to decipher the Indus Valley Script. Some researchers argue that the inscriptions weren’t even “true writing,” but perhaps something more of “an alternate symbolic system similar to emblems,” which may convey more generalised meanings. The Indus inscriptions themselves range from symbols that resemble animals (such as bulls or elephants) to simpler markings such as lines. When considering all of the characters that have been found, it’s explained that researchers have compiled between 400 and 700 distinct signs. Most inscriptions are rather brief, composed of an average of just four or five signs, the longest example, on the other hand, contains 30 characters.
An ongoing project
What’s also important to remember is that along with expert guidance, modern technology could also play a big role in making new breakthroughs. Better databases of texts and new computational methods for finding patterns among the script bring to light technology that may help to one day crack the code — or at least make some progress. In 2019 MIT researchers developed an algorithm “informed by patterns in how languages change over time.” The idea is to align words from a lost language in order to match their counterparts in a language that is already known, effectively ‘translating’ what may be possible to understand. The technology was tested on a language that took epigraphists nearly six decades to decipher (the language is known as Linear B, or the earliest form of Greek), in order to see if the technology could do what humans did but faster — ultimately producing results with “remarkable accuracy.” While technology highlights a future for the decipherment of the Indus script, it’s essential to realise that human research is still imperative to decoding the enigma.
The Indus Valley Civilisation is remarkable for a civilisation that existed over 4,000 years ago. There are still a great many aspects of this civilisation that are unknown. However with luck, diligent research and the application of new technology we can hope that the Indus Valley Script will be deciphered soon.
Articles you may also like
General History Quiz 37
The History Guild Weekly Quiz.See how your history knowledge stacks up. If you would like an invite to future quizzes please enter your details below. Subscribe * indicates required Email Address * First Name Last Name History Guild Weekly History Quiz Weekly New History Articles and News Monthly History Guild Update Please leave this field […]
The dark history of slavery and racism in Indonesia during the Dutch colonial period
Reading time: 7 minutes
The region near Medan is famous for its Deli tobacco, and colonial planters researched how to boost tobacco production. Behind the golden age and success of Dutch research, I found enormous human casualties that built plantations in North Sumatra. Widespread racism and slavery occurred in plantations managed by colonial companies.
315 nuclear bombs and ongoing suffering: the shameful history of nuclear testing in Australia and the Pacific
Reading time: 6 minutes
The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons received its 50th ratification on October 24, and will therefore come into force in January 2021. A historic development, this new international law will ban the possession, development, testing, use and threat of use of nuclear weapons.
The text of this article was commissioned by History Guild as part of our work to improve historical literacy. If you would like to reproduce it please get in touch via this form.
